Our sectors

We treat all personal data in accordance with our privacy policy.
Show Site Navigation

Northwick Park drug trial research published

Leigh Day solicitor Gene Matthews welcomes new drug trial research

Photo: istock

22 October 2008

New research from the Northwick Park drug trial highlights the need for EU legislation to ensure that information given to people enrolling on clinical trials is easily understood: Immediate steps are required in the meantime to protect patients Leigh Day solicitor Gene Matthews is representing a number of the men involved in the drug trial at Northwick Park and he welcomes this new research. He said:

" Our clients have made it clear from the outset that the drug trial documentation supplied by TeGenero & Parexel did not explain the serious risk to health posed by the TGN1412 drug trial. If this risk had been apparent from the documentation, our clients would never have volunteered to participate. Any steps to improve the quality and accessibility of information provided to potential drug trial volunteers is to be welcomed".

New research presented today shows that the information given to the volunteers of the disastrous Northwick Park “Elephant Man” trial would not have passed a ‘readability’ test. The research, presented at the international meeting of the Drug Information Association today, highlights an immediate need for all information provided to volunteers in clinical trials to be ‘User Tested’ before future trial protocols can be approved.

The University of Leeds commissioned Luto Research Ltd (Leeds University Testing Organisation) to undertake the User Testing component of the presented research, which highlighted that members of the public took up to an hour to find all of the answers to questions about key facts in the volunteer information provided – and with six of the 21 questions, at least 20 per cent of participants did not understand the key facts at all. The volunteers involved in the Elephant Man trial reported to the media, after their trial ordeal, that they were only given approximately 10 minutes to review their consent forms and the drug information sheet before entering into the clinical trial. User Testing, is a form of “readability” testing and is currently applied to patient information leaflets inside medicine packs to ensure that they are clearly written and can be understood by the target audience and it is required by EU law. However, this law does not currently extend to participant information provided to people about medicines within clinical trials, which could be licensed or unlicensed.

“In light of this new research, common sense would dictate that if there is current EU legislation around the need for User Testing information provided to patients about established medicines, the same standards should be applied for information given to patients about un-licensed, and as yet un-proven, medicines, where the volunteer is at a higher degree of risk. In the meantime I have written to Research Ethics Committees asking them if they will take steps to include the User Testing of information intended for trial volunteers before they approve any clinical trial protocols. The UK could take a lead in Europe in this initiative – in the way that the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) did to ensure a thorough and consistent approach to User-Testing licensed medicines”, commented Professor DK Theo Raynor, Professor of Pharmacy Practice, University of Leeds.

For more information please contact Gene Matthews on 020 7650 1200.

Information was correct at time of publishing. See terms and conditions for further details.

Information was correct at time of publishing. See terms and conditions for further details.

Share this page: Print this page